cookie mocktails
The Thin Mint
A rich dark chocolate and fresh mint mocktail with a chocolate-mint rim — the iconic cookie in a glass.
8 min1Easy
cookie mocktails · alcohol-free
The Tagalong Temptation
A rich peanut butter and chocolate mocktail with a chocolate-peanut butter rim — Tagalong cookies in a glass.
Recipe guidanceClear ingredients, preparation steps, serving yield, and optional swaps for home mixing.
Prep time
10 min
Total time
10 min
Serves
1
Difficulty
Medium
Bright & refreshing
A balanced alcohol-free drink built around real citrus and fruit flavor.
Simple ingredients
Easy-to-find ingredients and an approachable home-bar method.
Perfect for occasions
Made for an everyday treat, dinner party, or celebratory pour.
Ingredients
Makes 1 serving. Ingredient quantities update with the selected batch size.
- 2 tablespoons creamy peanut butter
- 2 oz warm simple syrup (to blend with peanut butter)
- 1 oz dark chocolate syrup
- 3 oz whole milk (or oat milk)
- Chocolate syrup + crushed peanuts, for rim
- Ice
- Peanut butter cup, for garnish
Step-by-Step Instructions
- 1
Prepare the glass
Make peanut butter syrup: blend 2 tablespoons peanut butter with 2 oz warm simple syrup until completely smooth.
- 2
Build the drink
Prepare the rim: drizzle chocolate syrup around the rim of a rocks glass, then dip into crushed peanuts.
- 3
Add the finishing touch
In a shaker, combine peanut butter syrup, dark chocolate syrup, and milk with ice.
- 4
Garnish & serve
Shake vigorously for 20 seconds — the peanut butter needs to fully incorporate.
- 5
Garnish & serve
Double-strain into the prepared glass over fresh ice.
- 6
Garnish & serve
Garnish with a mini peanut butter cup on a cocktail pick.
Recipe Tips
- Blend the peanut butter and simple syrup while the syrup is warm — it incorporates much more smoothly.
- For a frozen version, blend all ingredients with 1 cup of ice until smooth.
- Oat milk gives a slightly sweeter, creamier result than regular milk for this recipe.
Make It Your Own
For a crowd: Batch the liquid base, but save cookie crumbles, whipped topping, or a decorative rim for individual glasses so the presentation stays neat.
Easy swaps: Use crushed graham crackers or a similar cookie for a compatible rim. Use vanilla or chocolate syrup as a simple stand-in for a specialty dessert flavor.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this sweet enough for dessert?
Yes, but you can increase sweetness gradually after tasting the chilled drink.
Can I skip the cookie garnish?
Absolutely. The liquid base is designed to stand on its own.
Keep exploring
More Mocktails You'll Love
cookie mocktails
The Samoa Swirl
A rich caramel-coconut mocktail with a toasted coconut rim and chocolate drizzle — Samoa cookies in a glass.
12 min1Medium
cookie mocktails
The Toffee-tastic Dream
A golden butterscotch-toffee mocktail with a caramel rim and toffee bits — Toffee-tastic cookies in a glass.
8 min1Easy
You Might Also Like
More zero-proof recipes with a similar flavor path.
world cup-2026
Oranje Stroopwafel — Netherlands
A warm golden caramel and cinnamon drink inspired by Dutch stroopwafels — the Netherlands' most beloved street snack in liquid form.
5 min1Easy
city signatures
Miami Sunset Paloma (Zero-Proof)
A Miami Sunset Mocktail inspired by a zero-proof Paloma, with grapefruit, guava nectar, a hibiscus float, and a Tajín rim.
10 min1Medium
city signatures
NYC Skyline Spritz
A bold, sophisticated New York-inspired spritz with cranberry, ginger, and a blackberry garnish — as iconic as the skyline.
5 min1Easy
city signatures
Atlanta Peach Smash
A sweet Southern peach smash with fresh peaches, mint, and honey — Georgia's finest in a glass.
8 min1Easy
Explore More Recipe Collections
Coconut Mocktail Recipes
Explore creamy and tropical coconut mocktail recipes with coconut milk, cream, water, and toasted coconut—made with existing zero-proof drinks.
Dinner Party Mocktails
Serve sophisticated dinner party mocktails with fruit, tea, herbs, spice, and fresh bubbles. Existing alcohol-free recipes for a thoughtful table.
Non-Alcoholic Drinks for New Year's Eve
Celebrate NYE without alcohol — sparkling mocktails, champagne alternatives, and midnight toast drinks that look and taste as festive as the real thing.